• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Paradise Pizza

**About Paradise Pizza**

Located in Wallingford, CT, Paradise Pizza has become a beloved local hotspot for pizza and Italian cuisine. Known for its exceptional flavor, the pizzeria offers much more than just pizza; from satisfying grinders to comforting pasta dishes, every bite is crafted with care. Customers praise the friendly owners, who epitomize the heart of small-town dining. Signature dishes like garlic knots and the legendary Paradise Specials leave patrons raving about their experiences. With top-notch service and a commitment to quality, Paradise Pizza stands out as a true gem in the culinary landscape, inviting you to discover a slice of heaven.

Paradise Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Just me Valerie
Just me Valerie

We have had grinders and they were really satisfying, but today was the first time we ordered pizza. It was SOOOO good. We have our new pizza place! It’s across town, but worth it. Better than all the other ones we pass to get there.

Scott Philbrick
Scott Philbrick

We love this place! The owners are awesome ‘salt of the earth’ types! The food is excellent, and if there is an issue, they will go out of their way to make oh e it right! Thanks for all the years of Paradise Specials!! Amended: still the best little pizza joint in Wallingford! Pictures added! Look at all the garlic on the Broccoli, and these Garlic Knots!!! Forget about it! Heaven! Go he’s some tonight!

Scott Kruitbosch
Scott Kruitbosch

I stopped by Paradise Pizza one night after my partner and I photographed an engagement session for a couple a few minutes away. We were looking to grab some grinders and it was late, but we were lucky and LOVED our food. Every time we work in the area we stop by for a sandwich, pasta, or a couple apps. One night I was taking our to go order and they asked if I wanted a free large pizza as apparently the customer was not going to pick it up or had canceled the order. It was so kind of them, and the half bacon/half pepperoni was fantastic! As a pizza lover with high standards, I was impressed - so great, now we have even more difficult choices to make when ordering here with seemingly everything being delicious. Thanks again!

Greg Carr
Greg Carr

I asked for chicken parm dinner a la vodka. These guys knew exactly what I wanted. They served it with garlic knots. This is real east coast italian. Just order from these guys!

Althea M
Althea M

Delivery was right on time and they took extra care to not let it get rained on, my whole order was correct, and the food was all delicious. Will definitely order from here again in the future.

Tomasita Soto
Tomasita Soto

I placed an order for delivery today and got the wrong dinner, I called and spoke to someone and I got my correct meal delivered right away. Great customer service and will continue to order from there!

Emily Schatten
Emily Schatten

Delicious food and always a good experience! Would recommend the paradise combo pie and potato skins.

Sally Comrie
Sally Comrie

I ordered a large veggie pizza, light on the cheese and heavy on the spinach. OMG! This pizza was absolutely so delicious. Lots of fresh veggies, and the crust was perfect. Friendly and kind staff are very welcoming and the service was quick. You have got to try their food- totally worth every penny.

Location

  • Paradise Pizza
    624 S Colony St, Wallingford, CT 06492, United States Hotline: +1 203-294-9494

Welcome to Paradise Pizza, a hidden gem located at 624 S Colony St, Wallingford, CT. This delightful eatery is not just about pizza; it's a celebration of authentic East Coast Italian cuisine. If you're searching for a place where food meets warmth and community, look no further.

The charm of Paradise Pizza is palpable the moment you step through the door. Both owners are known for their genuine hospitality, earning them the affection of loyal patrons. As one customer aptly described, they are "salt of the earth" types who ensure each dining experience is accompanied by a smile and attentive service.

While the grinders have long been a crowd favorite, it’s the pizza that truly shines and has secured Paradise Pizza's status as the go-to spot for many. One thrilled diner exclaimed, “It was SOOOO good,” declaring their first pizza experience from Paradise as spectacular enough to make it their new favorite, even if it is a bit of a trek across town. With reviews like this, it's clear they're doing something special.

The menu boasts an array of delectable offerings, from comforting garlic knots—"Forget about it! Heaven!"—to mouthwatering pizza topped with generous portions of pepperoni and bacon. Customers often rave about the thoughtful servings, like when one reviewer received a complimentary large pizza due to a canceled order, a testament to the kindness ingrained in this establishment's philosophy.

For those craving Italian classics, try the chicken parmesan a la vodka or their flavorful pasta dishes. It's evident from the reviews that every dish is crafted with care and authenticity. As one regular noted, ordering from Paradise Pizza means never having to make a tough choice—the quality and taste of everything on the menu are simply outstanding, making it a feast for both the eyes and the palate.

The commitment to customer satisfaction extends beyond just the food. With punctual deliveries and careful handling of orders, Paradise Pizza ensures that every meal arrives as intended—delicious and ready to enjoy. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or having it delivered, you can expect nothing short of excellence.

So, why not treat your taste buds to a slice of this culinary paradise? Visit Paradise Pizza today, or call them at +1 203-294-9494, and discover your new favorite spot for Italian delights right here in Wallingford. You won't regret it!